To Be Read: Jane Porter

As part of my New Year’s Resolutions, I am working through my To Be Read shelf and tracking the books I read in an effort to be more mindful about my reading and more critical in my thinking.

I read two more books from my To Be Read pile, which means I’m (so far) staying on schedule. Both books, The Frog Prince and Mrs Perfect, are by the same author: Jane Porter. It wasn’t until I was about a third of the way through Mrs Perfect that I realized that is was a sequel of sorts to the Porter’s first book, which I also read, called Odd Mom Out. Now that I have the perspective of the adversary (the novel starts with a fairly antagonistic relationship between two of the main characters), I’d be interested in going back to read Marta’s story.

Both books are fairly fluffy and I don’t think I will keep either of them. Both books have main characters going through a period of tumult, followed by personal growth. I liked that The Frog Prince didn’t have what you would think of as a HEA (the main character finds happiness with herself, not a man, although romantic prospects are on the horizon). The main character in Mrs Perfect seemed too perfect, and the supporting characters of her husband, in-laws, most friends and kids weren’t fully fleshed out enough. Taylor, aka Mrs Perfect, is a strong organized sort who comes from nothing and is strong enough to overcome her problems through brute force of will, which is a trait that of course speaks strongly to me. Holly, from The Frog Prince, starts off weak and then grows stronger through discovering her inner strength. Again, the supporting case was only roughly sketched out, not fully developed, which makes the baddies fairly stereotypical although there are a few surprising moments. Religion makes enough of an appearance in both books that I suspect the author is a fairly devout Christian or has been in the past, although it’s more of a dog whistle and less “if you believe in God good things are going to happen to you”.

Odd Mom Out and Mrs Perfect both take place in Bellevue and East Side moms and Microsoft culture are big players. As someone who is still relatively new to Microsoft (compared to the people who have been there long enough to be Microsoft Millionaires) and fairly low down in the ranks (compared to the people who have been there long enough to be Microsoft Millionaires) the stories weren’t very familiar. On the other hand we have chosen to live in Seattle, away from all that, and I do intentionally stay away from those kinds of competition (like with the Room Moms at View Ridge).

These books both definitely fall into chick lit territory and remind me a lot of Jane Green’s earlier work: good reads, quick reads, reads that cheer you up while you’re reading them but that don’t necessarily stick with you. In short, I’m happy to have read both both books, but I won’t keep either.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s